Why isn't there a GTA or Red Dead Redemption movie?



  • Thanks to the success of current projects like: Hollywood is finally managing to properly implement video game adaptations
    The last of us
  • Rockstar Games, known for
    Red Dead Redemption
    refuses to risk its intellectual property with film adaptations, and fans support it.
  • Attempting to adapt the complex and cinematic stories of
    Red Dead Redemption
    to film would probably be a daunting task.

Video game Adaptations are the next big thing in the film industry. Hollywood has been trying to bring popular video game franchises to the big screen for decades, with limited success. Only in recent years has Hollywood begun to correct the formula of a good video game adaptation. After the groundbreaking success of HBO The last of us, new video game adaptations are being greenlit left, right and center. Prime Video will be released this year alone Stand out Series, Arcane Season 2, the ankle series, and Sonic the Hedgehog 3to name a few.

Jack Black is expected to star in another video game adaptation: Eli Roth's border areas Movie. The film brings to life the diverse characters, slapstick humor and exciting action of the popular first-person shooter series. Jack Black is known to be a gamer himself and previously ran his own gaming YouTube channel. But among the countless video game adaptations announced, two major titles have yet to receive a live-action adaptation, and Jack Black (understandably) can't understand why.

A bad GTA or Red Dead Redemption movie would ruin the franchise's reputation

While the video game industry has slowly evolved toward “cinematic” video games over the past few decades, one company has embraced this style from the start. Rockstar Games are the famous developers of two of the most acclaimed video game franchises of all time: Grand Theft Auto (GTA) And Red Dead Redemption. If you know anyone who has played the recent entries in either of these two franchises, they've probably mentioned once or twice (or endlessly) how cinematic they are. According to his recent interview with TotalFilm, Jack Black feels the same way.

“I can’t believe they haven’t already started filming one of the Rockstar Games.”

This is an opinion that fans have shared for years, but there have actually been attempts to make films from Rockstar Games' popular IPs. Speaking to The Guardian in 2013, Rockstar Games co-founder Dan Houser talked about previous pitches for a GTA movie. “We have been made offers many times and have never been appealed. The money was never nearly worth risking his crown jewels.”

“Our little experiments with Hollywood have kept us turning to games.”

Ultimately, Rockstar Games' decision to forego live-action adaptations must be praised. Houser's comments illustrate the company's protectiveness of its most successful intellectual properties. In the age of unnecessary reboots, franchises and legacy sequels, a company that refuses to sell its soul to the Hollywood meat grinder is incredibly respectable and unimaginable to some.


The Sims film adaptation with Margot Robbie and Marvel director

A film based on the best-selling video game “The Sims” is currently in development.

Of course, Houser's comments don't just come from a place of artistic integrity. A bad GTA movie could potentially destroy the franchise's phenomenal reputation among fans. At the time of publication GTA V is just behind it as the third best-selling video game of all time, with around 195 million copies sold Minecraft And Tetris. Rockstar Games wants to break this record when the time comes GTA VI Releases in 2025. Any negative press surrounding the GTA Franchises, including a bad film adaptation, could potentially decline GTA VIProjected sales will decline and the franchise's popularity and reputation will be drastically reduced.

Rockstar Games wants “total creative control” over GTA and Red Dead Redemption

That doesn't mean that a GTA or Red Dead Redemption Movie (or series) will never happen, but it is highly unlikely. With the reputation of their two biggest IPs at stake, Rockstar Games wants to have complete creative control over every possible adaptation to ensure the highest quality.


Jack Black is ready for School of Rock 2, but he has one condition

School of Rock celebrated its 20th anniversary last year. So is it time for a sequel?

In 2019, Strauss Zelnick, the CEO of Take-Two Interactive (the parent company of Rockstar Games), spoke to The Wrap about possible film adaptations from Rockstar Games. Regarding Houser's comments about protecting the reputation of their intellectual property, Zelnick added: “They own the most valuable intellectual property ever created by humanity: Grand Theft Auto… Are we really going to give this up and hope that someone, no matter how talented they are, does a really good job with it?” As frustrating as it is for fans of both games to hear that GTA or Red Dead Redemption Although the film will (probably) never happen – like Houser's statement in 2013 – it must be respected.

However, part of the Rockstar Games fan base believes that any attempts at a GTA or Red Dead Redemption Film would be unnecessary. The latest entries in both franchises, GTA V And Red Dead Redemption 2are widely considered two of the most cinematic video games ever produced, with incredible stories. Although they are set in an open world, their plots and cutscenes are on the same level as some of the best Hollywood films of the last few decades.

Additionally, both video games have much longer running times to explore their stories and expand their characters. It takes approximately 52 hours to complete a single game Red Dead Redemption 2, and as a result, much of the side content available in the game is missing. Condensing the complexity of such a vast narrative into a single feature film is a Herculean task that is doomed to failure. Hopefully the numerous upcoming video game adaptations will be based on this The last of us and have success. Jack Black stars in Eli Roth's alongside Cate Blanchett, Jamie Lee Curtis and Kevin Hart border areas. border areas hits theaters on August 9th.